Level · Rooster
Role · Creator
One PieceWhich captain would you have wanted?
Luffy
Roger
Shanks
One PieceThe community has spoken. Discover the world ranking, compare it to yours and see how everyone else voted.



Shanks1581
Luffy1578
Whitebeard1543
Roger1513
Rocks D. Xebec1488
Doflamingo1485
Ace1460
Law1409
Blackbeard1388
Boa Hancock1359
Kid1346
Kaido1310
Buggy1306
Zeff1297
Hajrudin1293
Fisher Tiger1287
Big Mom1286
Shiki1262
Bonney1257
Bartolomeo1248
Bege1241
Usopp1217
Cavendish1212
Drake1207
Orlumbus1165
Yorki1160
Hawkins1150
Gecko Moria1141
Aladdin (assumed)1138
Sai1132
Brownbeard1130
Kuro1118
Bellamy1114
Arlong1111
Urouge1096
Ideo1081
Don Krieg1059
Roshio1037
Puzzle1037
Wapol1034
Foxy1010
Hody Jones1009
Apoo1002
Barbarossa981
Alvida973
Mikazuki968
Caribou968
Bluejam944
Vander Decken IX940
Demalo Black93020051 duels later, Luffy remains #1 in the One Piece captain ranking with 1596 ELO points, while Whitebeard holds second place at 1560.
Luffy's dominance at the top stems from a 72% win rate across 748 duels, outpacing Whitebeard by 36 ELO points. Just 1 point separates Whitebeard from Shanks at rank 3, making the podium's middle positions fiercely contested. The sharpest divide appears between ranks 4 and 5, where a 67-point gap splits Roger from Ace, marking the boundary between legendary captains and the rest of the field. Roger's placement at rank 4 with 1532 points and a 67% win rate suggests the Pirate King's reputation still commands respect, even if nostalgia doesn't guarantee him a podium finish. At the bottom, Demalo Black languishes at rank 50 with 900 ELO points and a 26% win rate, proving that impersonating the Straw Hat captain earns no favor from voters. Bluejam and Vander Decken IX round out the cellar, their low rankings reflecting the community's judgment on captains whose cruelty or obsession overshadowed their leadership.
This ranking draws from 20051 duels submitted by 108 players, sorting through 50 contenders to determine which One Piece captain fans would most want to follow. The data was updated on 10 October 2026. Vote now to shape the hierarchy and settle which captain truly deserves your loyalty on the high seas.
Updated on October 10, 2026
Every duel won lifts a contender and every loss drops them, by an amount that depends on the opponent's strength: beating the leader is worth more than beating the last. It is an ELO, the same principle as in chess. Duels are not drawn at random — an adaptive entropy sort puts the least predictable match-ups first, which settles the ranking far faster than a full round robin. A worldwide ranking is only published past 30 completed plays. Known limit: a contender who has faced few opponents keeps an approximate score, and the bottom of the table moves more than the podium.
How other members ranked this list.
Level · Rooster
Role · Creator
One Piece
Luffy
Roger
Shanks
Level · Chick
One Piece
Shanks
Luffy
Law
Level · Turkey
Role · Creator
One Piece
Yorki
Usopp
Luffy
Level · Turkey
One Piece
Barbe Noire
Boa Hancock
Luffy
Level · Turkey
One Piece
Roger
Barbe Blanche
Shanks
Level · Turkey
One Piece
Luffy
Ace
Barbe BlancheNo comments yet
Be the first to share your take on this ranking.