CinemaclapperSpider-Man

Best Spider-Man actor

The community has spoken. Discover the world ranking, compare it to yours and see how everyone else voted.

versus3contendershigh-voltage426votestrophy166TopListcomment0commentsUpdated on 11/16/2026 at 06:00 AM
Tobey Maguire
Tobey Maguire1231
medal-1-3d

The worldwide ranking generated by 426 votes

3 / 3
medal-1
Tobey MaguireTobey Maguire1231
medal-2
Andrew GarfieldAndrew Garfield1186
medal-3
Tom HollandTom Holland1170

What the community says

Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield or Tom Holland: who's the best Spider-Man on screen? Vote for your fave actor in this Marvel showdown!

How this ranking is computed

Every duel won lifts a contender and every loss drops them, by an amount that depends on the opponent's strength: beating the leader is worth more than beating the last. It is an ELO, the same principle as in chess. Duels are not drawn at random — an adaptive entropy sort puts the least predictable match-ups first, which settles the ranking far faster than a full round robin. A worldwide ranking is only published past 30 completed plays. Known limit: a contender who has faced few opponents keeps an approximate score, and the bottom of the table moves more than the podium.

How our rankings are made →

Community TopList

How other members ranked this list.

guigzzzUser
level-2Level · Chick
Top 3
clapperSpider-Man

Which actor plays Spider-Man the best? 🕷️

  1. #1
    Tobey Maguire
  2. #2
    Tom Holland
  3. #3
    Andrew Garfield
zabelUser
level-2Level · Chick
Full
clapperSpider-Man

Which actor plays Spider-Man the best? 🕷️

  1. #1
    Andrew Garfield
  2. #2
    Tobey Maguire
  3. #3
    Tom Holland
sylvainUser
level-4Level · Turkey
Full
clapperSpider-Man

Which actor plays Spider-Man the best? 🕷️

  1. #1
    Tobey Maguire
  2. #2
    Andrew Garfield
  3. #3
    Tom Holland
rilon974Creator
level-3Level · Roostercreator-medalRole · Creator
Full
clapperSpider-Man

Which actor plays Spider-Man the best? 🕷️

  1. #1
    Andrew Garfield
  2. #2
    Tom Holland
  3. #3
    Tobey Maguire
tonikroosUser
level-4Level · Turkey
Full
clapperSpider-Man

Which actor plays Spider-Man the best? 🕷️

  1. #1
    Andrew Garfield
  2. #2
    Tobey Maguire
  3. #3
    Tom Holland
ju-bei-jrUser
level-2Level · Chick
Full
clapperSpider-Man

Which actor plays Spider-Man the best? 🕷️

  1. #1
    Andrew Garfield
  2. #2
    Tobey Maguire
  3. #3
    Tom Holland

0Comments

Sign in to join the conversation

Create an account to post, like and reply to other rankers.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your take on this ranking.

Similar TopList

Spider-Man
clapperSpider-Man
Quel est ton film préféré ? 🕸️
Honics
versus9high-voltage4.2ktrophy228
Spider-Man
clapperSpider-Man
Quel est ton costume préféré ? 🕸️
Honics
versus11high-voltage4ktrophy163
Spider-man
clapperSpider-man
Quel est ton spider-man préféré ?
Looky
versus16high-voltage3.1ktrophy70
Spider-man PS5
jvSpider-man PS5
Quel est ton costume de Peter préféré ?🕷
Ikaris
versus88high-voltage5.8ktrophy15